Katie Zacharia, who briefly served as White House press secretary for five days in October, says the Republican Party simply lacks the instincts to win elections, pointing to this month’s historic midterm losses that cost the GOP nine Senate seats and at least 50 House seats.
“The Republicans are terrible at the offense,” Zacharia told The Free Press. “I mean, we can’t win. We’re not good at winning.”
She argued Democrats don’t have a particularly persuasive bench of their own, but have relied on anti-Trump sentiment to drive turnout. “There’s nobody persuasive in the Democrats, but they’ve always banked on Trump Derangement Syndrome,” she said.
Zacharia’s brief tenure ended after a difficult run of press briefings and questions about her legal credentials. President Trump told reporters at the time that he had informed her, “You don’t have to do this if you don’t want to. I think you should reconsider.”
Despite the rocky exit, Zacharia said she holds no grudge and has no plans to air grievances about her time in the administration. “There’s nothing terrible to write,” she said, adding that her profile has only grown since leaving the post. “President Trump made me famous. I can’t even keep up. I had to hire someone to go track all my opportunities.”
Echoing Trump on Forgiveness
Zacharia also aligned herself with Trump’s recent comments on forgiving political enemies. In a “60 Minutes” interview this month, correspondent Ross Douthat asked Trump whether he would forgive his enemies if the question arose at the gates of Heaven. Trump answered, “I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will.”
Zacharia said she agreed with that sentiment and has struggled with the idea of praying for people who have wronged her. “I respect him for saying it,” she said. “That’s how we all feel. I had friends telling me after everything that happened that I needed to be praying for my enemies, and I was like, ‘No, justice is the Lord’s, and sometimes you want to see retribution for those who have harmed you.'”
She went further, saying she personally could not forgive the person accused of killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk, though she suggested his widow might. “Erika might be able to, but I can’t,” Zacharia said.
Pushback on Faith and Politics
Democratic strategist Kaivan Shroff criticized Zacharia’s remarks as inconsistent with the Christian values Republicans often emphasize. “What jumped out to me was how casually she agreed with Trump that you shouldn’t forgive or pray for your enemies,” Shroff told Fox News Digital. “Republicans talk constantly about Christian values, but apparently one of Christianity’s clearest teachings becomes negotiable when Trump has a grievance.”
Shroff pointed to Texas, where Democratic Senator-elect James Talarico won his race partly by invoking religious themes — a sign, he argued, that the political landscape around faith is shifting. “We saw James Talarico succeed at pointing out a lot of those double standards when it comes to faith on the right,” Shroff said. “So it does seem that Republicans have ceded ground on the topic of faith with all of the Trump administration and MAGA hypocrisy around it.”
Fox News Digital reached out to the White House and to Zacharia for comment.
