More Americans are eating out alone, and some are asking restaurants for a favor that’s dividing opinion in the industry: half-size portions of full menu dishes.
Reservations for parties of one rose 22% year over year in the third quarter of 2025, according to restaurant technology company Toast. As solo dining grows more common, diners who still want to sample multiple dishes without ending up with more food than they can eat are increasingly asking servers whether they can order a half portion, Food & Wine reported.
Whether that request gets honored, and whether it should be made at all, has become a point of debate among diners online.
“Don’t even bother, order the regular meal. And when it comes, you eat what you want of it, and anything that you have left over, get a to go box and take it home,” one person wrote on Quora, adding that many restaurants view smaller portions for a single adult as a waste of kitchen time and effort.
Other diners say there’s no harm in asking. “It never hurts to ask!” another Quora user wrote, though they cautioned that success depends heavily on the dish itself.
Some Dishes Bend, Others Don’t
“Whether or not you are successful in your request depends on a few things. If the dish is pre-proportioned, then it’s not likely,” the commenter said. An entree built around a half lobster tail, for instance, isn’t something a kitchen can easily scale down. Restaurants may also decline to shrink whole fish and meat preparations, portioned desserts, or pizzas.
A Reddit user made a similar distinction, noting that pasta dishes are simpler to adjust because the pasta, sauce and garnish can all be portioned out while the rest is kept for other orders. “Not so easy with a piece of protein (1/2 steak, 1/2 fish filet, 1/2 burger) because those are generally pre-portioned for service,” they wrote.
Diners who do get a smaller portion shouldn’t necessarily expect a smaller bill, either. According to the Quora commenter, customers will likely pay full price for a half-sized dish because it takes the kitchen roughly the same amount of time and effort to prepare regardless of size.
Why Diners Want the Option
For some solo diners, the motivation isn’t variety but moderation. “I hate wasting food, but if I eat the full portion I’m overeating and will feel sick. I’d love to do a half portion for a slightly cheaper price and not overeat or waste food,” one commenter wrote.
Not everyone comes away empty-handed on price, though. One Reddit user said they were pleasantly surprised when a restaurant charged them exactly half the menu price for a half-sized portion.
For now, chefs appear split: some are happy to accommodate solo diners so they can try more of the menu without food waste, while others hold firm that kitchen labor and pre-portioned ingredients make the request impractical.
