A 76-year-old San Diego homeowner says a man she hired to fix her pipes instead took over her property, transferred her utility accounts into his name, and began renting rooms to more than a dozen people, many of them homeless, over a two-year ordeal that she says was prolonged by California’s tenant protection laws.
Jordy Smith told KGTV she temporarily left her home in the City Heights neighborhood after breaking a hip and hired an unnamed man she believed was a plumber to make repairs while she recovered. Instead, she says he locked her and her partner out and began filling the house with occupants.
“He just took over and, like, before we knew it, there was like 15 people,” Smith said.
Smith later learned the man was not a licensed plumber. Squatter Squad, a company Smith hired to remove the occupants, described an escalating situation in a social media post: “Boats were showing up. RVs were moving onto the property. More people were staying there. The contractor had started inviting others onto the property, renting out rooms and even charging people for RV space.”
Smith said she tried repeatedly to confront the people living in her home, but they would lock the door and refuse to speak with her. “I couldn’t sleep at night. I mean, it just seemed like we’d never get back home,” she said.
How California law slowed the removal
Under California law, anyone who continuously occupies a property for 30 days acquires “tenant-at-will” rights. Once that threshold passes, law enforcement treats the matter as a civil landlord-tenant dispute rather than criminal trespassing — meaning deputies cannot simply remove the occupants. The homeowner must instead pursue a formal eviction through the courts.
Squatter Squad told KGTV that squatter cases are “often treated as civil matters,” which makes it difficult for owners to reclaim their own property quickly.
Lando Thomas, owner of Squatter Squad, laid out the problem in a statement to Fox News Digital: “California’s tenant protection laws serve an important purpose, but they can also create unintended challenges when individuals unlawfully occupy properties. In some situations, the legal framework makes it difficult for law enforcement to quickly distinguish between legitimate tenants and individuals who have no lawful right to occupy a property. When that distinction cannot be established immediately, property owners may be forced into lengthy and costly legal proceedings to regain possession of their own property.”
He added: “The issue isn’t whether legitimate tenants deserve protection. They absolutely do. The issue is ensuring that those protections cannot be exploited by individuals who unlawfully occupy someone else’s property. We need a system that protects legitimate tenants while also providing property owners and law enforcement with a clear, efficient process for addressing unlawful occupancy.”
Squatter Squad shared video showing San Diego County Sheriff’s deputies confronting the occupants in August. The company said it worked with the sheriff’s department through the formal legal process, which ultimately required an eviction. “It took time. It even required an eviction. But in the end, we got the property back,” the company said.
Smith is now calling on state lawmakers to act. “Make some new laws and take care of the legitimate people that are having the problems because it really has caused a lot of stress for us a lot,” she said.
Fox News Digital has reached out to the San Diego County Sheriff’s Office for comment.
