Andrea Bartzen, the Palm Beach socialite labeled a “fake Cartier heiress” in a widely read exposé earlier this year, was turned away from a high-profile New York City event Monday night, according to multiple accounts.
Bartzen attempted to gain entry to a 25th anniversary celebration for chocolatier MarieBelle at the brand’s Broome Street store, but was stopped at the door. “She was trying to convince the publicist to let her in,” a source at the party said. “They wouldn’t let her in.”
The event was organized by longtime publicist Norah Lawlor, who splits her time between New York and Palm Beach, where she represents clients including real heiress Consuelo Vanderbilt Costin. Lawlor confirmed the incident directly.
“Andrea showed up,” Lawlor said. “She wasn’t on the guest list, she wasn’t invited.”
“I gave her a goodie bag. She asked to come back later and I said, ‘No. You are not on the list. I will invite you one day when it’s appropriate.'”
Lawlor added a blunt rule of thumb for party crashers: “Don’t go if you’re not invited. That’s the rules.”
Bartzen, for her part, offered a different version of events. She said she had arranged to be added as a plus-one by another guest attending the party, a claim that has been confirmed by that guest. The problem, she said, was that the request was never formally approved.
“I went to have a business meeting with someone there who was invited. I said please add me as a plus-one and get it confirmed … Norah, the gatekeeper, said ‘You didn’t RSVP personally,’ and so I said ‘Fine’ and didn’t go to the event.”
Bartzen said the meeting with her contact happened anyway, just not inside the store. “The girl that invited me stepped outside, we had a five-minute meeting and then I left,” she said. She went on to threaten legal action and accused reporters of “assault journalism.”
Guests who did make it onto the list for the MarieBelle anniversary party included designer Nicole Miller, Keiko Aoki and lifestyle expert Pamela Morgan.
A Pattern of Scrutiny
Bartzen has faced public scrutiny since March, when New York magazine published a lengthy investigation titled “The Fake Cartier and the Fake Rockefeller.” The piece accused Bartzen and her then-boyfriend, a magician the article alleged had falsely claimed ties to the Rockefeller family, of fabricating aristocratic backgrounds to crash elite social circles in Palm Beach, the Hamptons and elsewhere. Bartzen has lived in New York.
The magazine’s allegations went further, claiming Bartzen rented an apartment she did not own under a name resembling the actual owner’s, and promoted charity events for causes that reportedly never received the promised proceeds. Bartzen has denied the allegations and called the article a “hit piece.”
In April, a separate confrontation was reported in which a guest at one of Bartzen’s “Cocktails and Conversation” events, featuring a former professional athlete and a former Navy SEAL, accused her of fraud. Bartzen ejected the accuser from the event and defended her work in strong terms.
“I’m not gonna back down. I am here to help humanity and mental health. I won’t let someone try and stop me and lay down dead because they tried to kill me. I have a bigger soul purpose, to heal humanity, and that’s what this event was about.”
