Netflix’s new romantic thriller “Guarding Stars” pairs a fake-relationship plot with a bodyguard-and-client romance, and wraps it all around a stalker mystery set partly in small-town Montana. For viewers left puzzling over who was threatening the film’s movie-star hero, here is a rundown of the plot and how it resolves.
Directed by Elizabeth Allen Rosenbaum from a screenplay by Erin Cardillo and Richard Keith, the film is based on Katherine Center’s 2022 novel “The Bodyguard.” Leighton Meester plays Hannah Brooks, a former Marine working as a bodyguard for a New York City security firm. Jared Padalecki plays Jack Stapleton, an A-list action star who has been receiving threats from a stalker. His studio insists he hire protection before he travels home to Montana to see his ailing mother.
Hannah recently broke up with a co-worker, Robbie (Toby Sandeman), after he criticized her emotionally guarded personality and her kissing — a remark that earned him a punch in the throat. When Hannah’s boss assigns her to guard Jack on his trip to Montana, she agrees, bringing along part of the security team and keeping her role secret from Jack’s family.
The fake relationship begins
At the hospital, Jack’s mother, Connie (Andie MacDowell), mistakes Hannah for Jack’s new girlfriend. Connie, who is being treated for a tumor-related illness, has been told by doctors to avoid stress, so Jack and Hannah agree to keep up the ruse once the family insists Jack join them for Christmas at their Montana ranch.
At the ranch, tension surfaces between Jack and his younger brother, Hank (Noah Lalonde), over the death of their brother Drew. Jack explains that after moving to Los Angeles for his first big role, he came home showing off in a rented sports car. Drew drove them home, hit black ice, and crashed into a river; Jack could not free Drew from his seatbelt before he drowned. Hannah, in turn, opens up about losing two members of her unit in a bombing during her time as a Marine — the source of her habit of sleeping in closets and humming a wordless tune she later learns is “Beautiful Dreamer.”
The rodeo and the viral clip
Against Hannah’s warnings, Jack sneaks off to watch Hank compete at the local rodeo in their hometown, where he runs into old classmates Sheriff Sanderson (Walker Hayes) and Deputy Nadine Turner (Tess Degenstein), who mentions she has recently separated from her husband. A kiss between Jack and Hannah is caught on the rodeo’s kiss cam and goes viral, exposing Jack’s location to the public.
Soon after, a fight between Jack and Hank triggers a heart scare that sends Connie to the hospital, with paparazzi now swarming the family. Hank and Jack reconcile, clarifying that Hank’s anger was never about Drew’s death but about Jack leaving afterward.
Who is the stalker
When the Stapletons receive a threatening diorama depicting Hannah and Jack hanged, the security team devises a plan to draw out the stalker by using Jack as bait during the town’s Christmas parade. A man identified through facial recognition as Jesse, a dishonorably discharged service member, appears to be the suspect, prompting the team to rush Jack to safety in Deputy Nadine’s patrol car.
But Nadine never answers her radio. It turns out Nadine — not Jesse — is the stalker. She reveals she left her husband, Jesse, believing she and Jack, former high school robotics teammates, were meant to be together; once he took up with someone else, she resolved to kill him instead. Hannah pursues the car on horseback, fights her way onto the vehicle, and subdues Nadine with help from the security team, freeing Jack unharmed.
How it ends
Jack and Hannah tell the Stapleton family the relationship was fake, and Hannah, hurt that Jack insists his feelings weren’t real, returns to New York. Jack lets her go before his brother convinces him to chase after her. At her apartment door, Hannah rejects his declaration and claims she doesn’t feel the same — but Jack notices she avoided eye contact, a tell he had earlier identified as a sign of dishonesty.
He climbs the fire escape back to her apartment and finds her held at gunpoint by Jesse, Nadine’s ex-husband, who blames Hannah for his marriage falling apart. Jack is shot in the shoulder during the struggle, but Hannah subdues Jesse and the two are safe.
A year later, Jack and Hannah are back at the family ranch in Montana for Christmas, having just watched a fictionalized movie version of their story called “Guarded Hearts.” Jack proposes, Hannah accepts, and the film closes with a music video from Jack’s pop-star ex-girlfriend, Kennedy Monroe, played by Ava Max.
