A South Carolina circuit court judge has denied a bid by Alex Murdaugh’s defense team to throw out the double murder indictment against him, even while acknowledging that the lead investigator in the case gave the grand jury faulty information about blood evidence and ammunition.
Judge Debra R. McCaslin issued her ruling Friday, Nov. 13, following a pre-trial hearing in which Murdaugh’s attorneys argued that South Carolina Law Enforcement Division investigator David Owen misled grand jurors in ways that undermined the legitimacy of the indictment itself. McCaslin disagreed that dismissal was warranted.
“Even if the challenged testimony concerning the blood spatter on the T-shirt and shotgun ammunition were excluded from consideration by the grand jury, the remaining unchallenged evidence overwhelmingly established probable cause,” McCaslin wrote in her order.
Judge Rebukes Investigator, Stops Short of Misconduct Finding
Despite keeping the indictment intact, McCaslin did not spare Owen from criticism. She wrote that his failure to account for a laboratory report addressed directly to him before he testified was a serious oversight.
“Oversights of this nature undermine public confidence in the integrity of the criminal justice system,” McCaslin wrote.
The judge also found that information presented to the grand jury about shotgun ammunition was inaccurate, but she stopped short of concluding that anyone acted with intent to deceive.
“Even accepting that the challenged testimony was inaccurate, the record presented does not establish intentional fabrication or prosecutorial misconduct,” she wrote.
McCaslin said the defense remains free to attack the disputed forensic claims when the case goes before a jury rather than have it resolved through a pretrial dismissal.
“Any inconsistencies in prior investigative statements or forensic conclusions are matters properly addressed through cross-examination and impeachment at the upcoming trial, rather than through the pretrial dismissal of facially valid indictments,” she wrote.
Disputed Blood and Ammunition Evidence
At the center of the defense’s motion was testimony Owen gave regarding blood spatter allegedly found on the shirt Murdaugh wore on June 7, 2021, the night his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, were shot to death at the family’s Moselle property in Colleton County. Owen told the grand jury the spatter linked Murdaugh to the killings, even though earlier lab testing had failed to detect human blood on the garment.
At Murdaugh’s first murder trial, Owen testified that he had not intended to mislead the grand jury and said he had not seen the final SLED lab report until after the indictment was already handed down.
During the Nov. 13 hearing, prosecutors argued that negative blood test results did not automatically invalidate the spatter findings, pointing to further testing by a state expert suggesting that prior chemical treatment of the shirt could have produced false negatives. Prosecutors said the expert has continued to stand by his conclusions, and that Owen’s grand jury testimony reflected investigators’ genuine understanding of the evidence at the time.
The defense also challenged Owen’s claim that shotguns recovered from the Murdaugh property were loaded with the same combination of ammunition used to kill Paul. Murdaugh’s attorneys maintained that none of the shotguns actually found on the property matched the exact shell combination recovered at the murder scene.
Prosecutors conceded Owen’s description of the ammunition may have lacked precision but denied any intent to deceive. Lead prosecutor Creighton Waters told the court the testimony reflected the agent’s honest understanding at the time.
“This was not overtly false. This was what the agent understood at the time,” Waters said.
Background
Murdaugh was convicted of both murders in 2023, but the South Carolina Supreme Court later threw out those convictions after finding that former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill had improperly influenced the jury. His retrial is scheduled to begin April 5, 2027.
