The city of Charlotte is asking a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge to throw out a wrongful-death lawsuit filed by the family of Iryna Zarutska, arguing that governmental immunity shields the city from liability for the security failures the family says left the 23-year-old unprotected aboard the Lynx Blue Line light-rail system.
Zarutska, a Ukrainian refugee, was killed after Decarlos Brown Jr. allegedly stabbed her in the neck about four minutes after she boarded the train, having just left her shift at a local pizzeria. Surveillance video showing Brown seated behind her before the attack drew national attention to the case.
Zarutska’s family sued Charlotte and its private transit security contractor, Professional Police Services, in August, alleging that inadequate policing and security on the light-rail system left riders exposed to violent crime.
In a 34-page filing submitted Monday, Charlotte asked the court to dismiss all claims against the city, arguing that decisions over transit policing, crime prevention, security-contractor oversight and public-safety administration are government functions protected from lawsuits under North Carolina law.
The family’s complaint had anticipated that defense, arguing that Charlotte waived its immunity and that running a fare-charging light-rail system is a proprietary function rather than a governmental one, and therefore not shielded from suit.
Charlotte’s filing confirms several details at the center of the dispute: there was no private security guard in Zarutska’s train car at the time of the attack, Brown appears to have boarded without presenting a ticket or pass, and the Lynx system has no turnstiles or fare gates to control entry.
The family’s lawsuit argues that stronger fare enforcement, physical barriers and adequate security presence could have kept Brown off the train or prevented the attack. It points to findings from the North Carolina state auditor showing that Charlotte and the Charlotte Area Transit System had planned to spend roughly $2.23 million on safety and security equipment in 2025 but spent only about $470,000, leaving close to $1.76 million unspent and some planned security work unfinished.
The city disputes that it neglected passenger safety, saying CATS maintained contracted armed and unarmed security, coordinated with law enforcement, and pursued other public-safety initiatives before Zarutska was killed. Charlotte also argues that Brown’s failure to pay his fare gave no indication he intended to commit violence, and that none of the city’s decisions on security staffing, guard placement, surveillance or fare enforcement caused Zarutska’s death. The city maintains that responsibility for her death rests solely with Brown.
Should the judge allow any of the family’s claims to proceed, Charlotte argues it should not be required to pay the estate more than $1 million. The city is asking the court to dismiss all claims against it with prejudice, meaning the family could not refile them. The judge has not yet ruled on the motion.
