The South Carolina prosecutor who secured Susan Smith’s 1995 murder conviction is urging a state parole board to deny her release, arguing she would use social media attention to torment the father of the two sons she killed.
Smith will appear before a seven-member parole board in Columbia, South Carolina, on Thursday morning. She was convicted on two counts of murder and sentenced to life in prison, but under state law at the time, she became eligible for parole after serving 30 years.
Smith strapped her two young sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, into her car and let it roll into a lake on Oct. 25, 1994. Prosecutors said the killings were part of an effort to win back a former lover who did not want children. Smith initially told police a Black man had carjacked her with the children inside, a false account her then-husband believed as the couple pleaded publicly for the children’s return.
Rep. Tommy Pope, now speaker pro tempore of the South Carolina House of Representatives, prosecuted the case and told Fox News Digital that Smith would exploit public attention if freed.
“I think the difficulty if Susan was out, she would be on social media. She would love the attention. It would be in David’s face every day, and all he has ever talked about is justice for Michael and Alex,” Pope said.
Pope said David Smith, the boys’ father, has told him he has forgiven Susan Smith on religious grounds but still believes justice requires her to remain imprisoned.
“[David Smith is] very good about not being vindictive towards Susan from a biblical standpoint. He says he’s forgiven her. But he just thinks that justice ought to be served for those boys, and I fully agree,” Pope said.
Pope said he does not believe Smith was remorseful for the killings themselves, and argued the jury that convicted her intended for her to spend the rest of her life in prison rather than eventually walk free.
“The jury truly believed they were giving her a life sentence, that she would spend the rest of her time lamenting what she’d done in regard to Michael and Alex. And I think what we’ve seen is, unfortunately, Susan is more focused on Susan,” Pope said. “Her remorse is for her circumstances, not for those boys.”
Smith was denied parole at her first hearing in November 2024. Speaking to the board over Zoom at that hearing, she expressed regret.
“I know that what I did was horrible. And I would give anything if I could go back and change it,” she told the board. “I love Michael and Alex with all my heart.”
She also told the board her Christian faith has brought her forgiveness. “I am a Christian and God is a big part of my life. And I know he has forgiven me,” she said.
Pope said he intends to appear at every future parole hearing to oppose her release.
“I will be with the father of the boys, David Smith, every two years, as long as it takes to keep her where she is now,” Pope said.
