Washington voters approved Initiative 638 on Nov. 3 by a margin of more than 10 percentage points, establishing that eligibility for girls’ and women’s sports categories in the state be based on sex. Weeks later, the American Civil Liberties Union of Washington announced it will sue to block the measure from taking effect.
In response, the Alliance Defending Freedom has filed a motion to intervene in the ACLU’s lawsuit on behalf of Female Athletes United, a coalition of female athletes. Washington’s Attorney General’s Office has also indicated it will defend the ballot measure in court.
Washington was one of four states where voters took up the issue this election cycle. Arizona, Colorado and Nebraska also passed ballot measures addressing eligibility rules for women’s sports, according to results cited in the dispute.
Background: Title IX and the courts
Supporters of the initiative argue it restores protections intended under Title IX, the federal law passed to guarantee equal athletic opportunities for women. They say that without a sex-based eligibility standard, female athletes lose roster spots, records, medals and podium finishes to male competitors.
The dispute follows last summer’s U.S. Supreme Court ruling in State of West Virginia v. B.P.J., which held that states may enact laws protecting women’s sports categories based on sex. Twenty-seven states have now passed such legislation, according to the filing’s backers.
Among the cases cited by supporters of the Washington measure is that of Kallie Keeler, a Washington high school wrestler who was injured during a match against a competitor who was male; coaches and officials involved reportedly did not disclose this to her beforehand.
Supporters also point to a United Nations report documenting more than 600 female athletes across 29 sports who have been displaced from events, medals or rankings by male competitors, who collectively took more than 890 medals. In West Virginia, one male competitor reportedly defeated more than 470 girls across roughly 1,400 instances in a single sport, a case that led directly to the Supreme Court litigation.
One of the athletes involved in the Washington case has described competing in a state high school girls’ 4×400-meter relay against a team that included a male athlete previously classified in the boys’ category; that athlete went on to win the state championship in the girls’ 400-meter race two years in a row. The athlete has also filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights seeking an investigation into the state’s athletic eligibility policies.
The ACLU’s lawsuit seeks to have a state court set aside Initiative 638 despite its passage at the ballot box. The outcome will determine whether Washington’s voter-approved sex-based eligibility standard for girls’ sports takes effect or is struck down before it can be enforced.
