Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin told lawmakers Wednesday that travelers keeping their shoes on at airport checkpoints has never compromised safety, pushing back on an Arizona congressman who said a classified briefing from the department’s own inspector general left him “very concerned.”
“We have never put anyone at risk at all,” Mullin said during a House Homeland Security Committee hearing, responding to questions from Rep. Eli Crane, R-Ariz.
Mullin said DHS evaluates screening technology on a daily basis and that he personally met with DHS Inspector General Joseph Cuffari in a secure facility to go over the watchdog’s findings. “In fact, we addressed three of the four concerns,” Mullin said, adding that he believed the fourth issue had nothing to do with security. He did not detail what steps the department took on the three concerns or what the unresolved fourth issue involves.
Crane, who said he received a classified briefing from the inspector general, called the findings troubling and asked Mullin to continue the conversation privately rather than in open session.
A Policy Change Under Watch
The exchange renews scrutiny of a July 2025 decision by then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem to end routine shoe removal at TSA checkpoints nationwide. Noem said at the time that improved screening technology would let the agency move travelers through lines faster without sacrificing security. TSA officers retained the authority to require shoe removal for additional screening on a case-by-case basis.
Within weeks of that change, the inspector general sent a formal warning to DHS and TSA leadership about a screening weakness, according to questions entered into the Senate record in July. The watchdog’s office followed up with a final classified report on Nov. 1, 2025. A March memo reviewed by CBS News shows Cuffari was still waiting for a formal response from the agencies after a 90-day deadline had already passed.
A Senator’s Push for a Reversal
Sen. Maria Cantwell, D-Wash., asked TSA in April to suspend the policy until the identified weakness was fixed, according to the Senate record. Then-acting TSA Administrator Ha Nguyen McNeill responded in May, writing that “current intelligence and risk assessments indicate no direct, credible threats related to shoes.”
Mullin’s testimony Wednesday did not clarify whether the inspector general has actually signed off on the steps DHS says it has taken to resolve the watchdog’s concerns, leaving unanswered the core question Crane raised: whether the government can verify its own claim that travelers’ shoes pose no risk at the checkpoint.
