A new opinion column argues that President Trump has an opportunity to fix what the 1986 Reagan-era immigration overhaul failed to accomplish: pairing legal status for some long-term residents with enforcement that actually sticks.
The piece, published by Fox News opinion writer Mehek Cooke, contends that Washington’s immigration debate has been reduced to two extremes — mass deportation or blanket amnesty — and that both avoid the real problem created by decades of weak enforcement.
Cooke credits President Reagan’s 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act with granting legal status to nearly 2.7 million people while pairing it with employer sanctions and border funding that ultimately proved toothless. According to the column, employers were deemed compliant as long as I-9 documents appeared genuine, and a Government Accountability Office review found that 39% of unauthorized workers identified in five major cities used or were suspected of using fraudulent documents — with investigators often unable to prove employers knew.
By the 1990s, Cooke writes, a Congressional Research Service analysis found the unauthorized population had grown past its pre-1986 level, as border enforcement funding increases were undercut by unfilled positions, reduced agent time and failing equipment, per GAO findings.
Current negotiations
The column notes that Trump has opened immigration talks with Democrats while ruling out blanket amnesty, prioritizing removal of people with criminal records — including those convicted of murder, rape or drug offenses — while reviewing long-term residents with clean records on a case-by-case basis.
Cooke criticizes a Democratic proposal, the Protect Our Neighbors Act, which she says would let final removal orders expire after 10 years and create a path to permanent residency for certain illegal immigrants, calling it a plan that rewards people for evading enforcement long enough to qualify.
The column cites Trump-era enforcement data to argue he is negotiating from a position of strength: southwest border apprehensions in fiscal year 2026 fell roughly 95% below the Biden-era annual average, and Border Patrol reported its first fiscal year with zero releases into the United States.
What the column proposes
Cooke argues Congress should codify current border policies into law, mandate nationwide E-Verify, penalize employers who knowingly hire illegal labor, and limit future presidents’ ability to unwind these protections unilaterally. She proposes that any deal include enforcement benchmarks — public removal reporting, zero Border Patrol releases, and a year of fully operational nationwide employment verification — before any legal relief expands.
On relief for individuals, the column points to existing law allowing certain illegal immigrants in removal proceedings to seek cancellation of removal after 10 years of continuous presence, good moral character, no disqualifying convictions, and proof that removal would cause exceptional hardship to a U.S.-citizen or lawful-permanent-resident spouse, parent or child. An immigration judge has discretion over such cases, and Congress caps most grants at 4,000 per year — a limit Cooke says shows such relief is not equivalent to blanket amnesty.
The column also calls for Congress to fund additional immigration judges to reduce case backlogs and create a streamlined federal review process so judges receive verified case files more quickly.
Washington failed Reagan by trading permanent legal status for temporary enforcement promises.
Cooke concludes that Trump can apply what she describes as Reagan’s own standard — trust, but verify — by making border security permanent in law rather than dependent on any single administration’s policy choices.
