President Donald Trump is urging Senate Republicans to bypass the Senate’s “blue slip” tradition after Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) blocked judicial nominee Elliot Gaiser, escalating a public feud within the Texas GOP delegation.
Gaiser, who clerked for Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito and served as Solicitor General of Ohio, currently heads the Office of Legal Counsel at the Department of Justice. Cornyn has used the blue slip process, a Senate custom that lets home-state senators effectively veto judicial nominees, to hold up Gaiser’s confirmation. Cornyn is also reported to be blocking Wesley Hunt’s nomination as Ambassador to Saudi Arabia.
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) publicly pressed Cornyn on Saturday, arguing there isn’t enough time left before Democrats could take over to vet a replacement nominee Cornyn has proposed. Cornyn responded to Cruz on X, drawing further criticism.
Gaiser clerked in Texas for a year, has family in the state, and has worked on Texas-related cases, which supporters argue should satisfy any concerns about his ties to the state.
Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) also weighed in, defending Gaiser’s qualifications regardless of the dispute over his home-state connections.
I get it. And I don’t care if you swore. But this vacancy exists, we shouldn’t leave it to be filled by Democrats, and Elliott Gaiser would be a phenomenal judge—anywhere in America, including Texas.
Trump raised the issue directly in a Saturday morning phone interview with Fox News, calling for the Senate to go around the blue slip in this case. He noted there have been exceptions to the blue slip tradition in the past, said Cornyn would have lost the fight anyway, and said Cornyn “is doing a tremendous disservice” by blocking Gaiser.
The blue slip process has not been applied consistently in recent years. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA), who chairs the Senate Judiciary Committee, said in 2017 that he “won’t let senators abuse the blue slip to block qualified nominees for political or ideological reasons,” but he has continued to honor blue slips for district court nominees, a practice both parties have used at different times to block nominees they oppose.
