ESPN personality Stephen A. Smith is facing criticism after urging black NBA players to rally against the Los Angeles Lakers’ top white players, framing an upcoming playoff push in explicitly racial terms.
Speaking on ESPN, Smith said he wanted to motivate black players by pointing to the Lakers’ success and asking whether they would allow white teammates to win a championship.
“With all the money that’s being exchanged, you want little motivational nuggets to nudge cats a little bit. So, I’m looking at the brothers, and I’m saying, LA doing special things,” Smith said. “The Lakers are doing special things…I’m saying to you, I ain’t never seen what they assembled, what they’re being led by, deliver an NBA championship in my lifetime. And I don’t think I’m gonna see it this year.”
Smith went further, referring to the Lakers’ white players as “them” and suggesting black players effectively own the league.
“I’m gonna say it for them. I’m looking at the fellas. LA looks pretty damn good. These white brothers can play, they can play. They can win a championship. This is the NBA! Y’all gonna let them win a championship?” he said.
The remarks prompted swift pushback, including from Smith’s own ESPN colleague Jay Williams, who called the comments “disturbing.”
“[They] sound like something you’d hear in the 1930s or 1940s, just with the racial dynamics reversed,” Williams said. “We spent generations fighting to ensure athletes were judged by their talent, not the color of their skin. Now we’re openly questioning whether Black players should allow white players to win? At what point does fighting against discrimination turn into perpetuating the same mentality we fought so hard to overcome?”
Rather than walk back the comments, Smith dismissed Williams’ criticism on X.
“Thanks for reaching out, Jay Williams. Always appreciate it! You can bring up that b.s. all you want about the 1930’s, but I’m talking about right now. I love this challenge to the fellas. I want to see if this generation of players are gonna succumb to these Lakers,” Smith wrote.
The episode drew reaction well beyond ESPN’s own ranks. Commentator Clay Travis asked what the reaction would be if a white broadcaster suggested white NFL quarterbacks needed to stop a black quarterback from winning a Super Bowl, suggesting such a comment would end a broadcaster’s career. Former NBA player Chandler Parsons predicted ESPN would “just let this slide, I guess.”
Former NFL player and current NBC analyst Doc Holiday also criticized Smith’s framing on X: “Why does it gotta be black versus white?… I don’t understand how that’s relevant.”
California sports reporter Fred J. Robledo offered a comparison on X, asking listeners to imagine a pundit telling white golfers during Tiger Woods’ rise that they shouldn’t let him win.
As of now, Smith has not issued any further response beyond his initial reply to Williams, and ESPN has not publicly commented on the matter.
