In a recent virtual event, Mayor Eric Adams of New York City suggested the possibility of offering lifeguard jobs to migrants, citing their proficiency in swimming as a key factor.
The statement made by Mayor Adams has sparked discussions and debates among various groups regarding the appropriateness and feasibility of such a proposal.
During the virtual event, Mayor Adams mentioned that migrants, particularly those from coastal areas or regions with access to water bodies, tend to be skilled swimmers due to their familiarity with aquatic environments.
He proposed that utilizing this skillset could potentially address the shortage of lifeguards in the city while also providing job opportunities for migrants who may be seeking employment.
“Let me just take your imagination for a moment. If we had a migrant and asylum seeker plan that states ‘Those jobs that we are in high demand, we could expedite [work permits],’” Adams said:
How do we have a large body of people that are in our city and country, that are excellent swimmers, and at the same time we need lifeguards? And the only obstacle is that we won’t give them the right to work to become a lifeguard. That just doesn’t make sense. But if we had a plan that says ‘We have a shortage of food service workers, those who fit the criteria, we’re going to expedite you.’ [Emphasis added]
…
We have all these eligible people waiting to work with the skills they need to fill the jobs but we’re unable to allow them to work because bureaucracy is in the way. That just does not make sense. [Emphasis added]
The idea put forth by Mayor Adams has received mixed reactions from different sectors of society.
Proponents of the proposal argue that it would not only help meet the demand for lifeguards in NYC but also give migrants a chance to contribute positively to their new community.
They view it as a practical solution that aligns with the city’s need for qualified individuals in crucial roles.
On the other hand, critics have raised concerns about the potential implications of such a policy. Some have questioned whether prioritizing migrants for lifeguard positions could disadvantage local residents who may also be interested in these jobs.
Additionally, there are apprehensions about the logistical challenges involved in implementing such a program and ensuring that all candidates meet the necessary qualifications and training requirements.
The discussion surrounding Mayor Adams’ suggestion reflects broader debates on immigration policy, labor market dynamics, and public safety considerations.
(Let’s just for a second imagine if it was Donald Trump who made the suggestion…)
As cities like New York continue to navigate complex issues related to employment and integration, finding innovative solutions that balance diverse interests remains a significant challenge.
As this conversation unfolds, stakeholders from different sectors will likely continue to express their perspectives on how best to approach this issue.
Ultimately, decisions regarding employment policies must take into account both practical considerations and ethical principles to ensure positive outcomes for all individuals involved.
Mayor Eric Adams’ suggestion regarding offering lifeguard jobs to migrants based on their swimming abilities has ignited discussions about immigration, employment opportunities, and public safety in New York City.
ICYMI: White House Claims Trials Against Trump Are “Related to 2024 Elections”
5 Comments
Knowing how to swim is only the beginning of being a lifeguard. Training on rescue methods is important, especially coastal waters. Being Illegals is another can of worms.
1st you would have to care about the people your going to rescue
Absolutely! James, upvote for your comment!
Who wrote this? Objections are being made in this piece, having nothing to do with the proposal. The proposal was not to prioritize migrants. There is a shortage of lifeguards in the city, and this is a suggestion on how to feel the need what’s the problem? As for the implication of racism, That is simply insanity in action.
So how do they know they are expert swimmers. Is it because they crossed the Rio Grand and made it. Or did they get to fill out an immediate job application when they illegally entered the United States. What about the ones whose dream is to be a roofer?? Should they give up that dream. You know, follow your heart and all of that